Wednesday, July 25, 2012

Welcome BBC readers!

A warm welcome to readers who followed the link from my BBC article! Make yourselves comfortable, have a look around. I have an archive on the side as well as a tag cloud. If there are any stories you feel are missing - drop me a line and I'll see what I can do! My main focus is reporting on European stories of academic misconduct for an English-speaking audience.

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Breaking the Spell of Silence

I have offered Conrad Kunze from the University of Cottbus guest blogging rights. This is his article about deciding to discuss plagiarism at a university that thinks 44 % pages with plagiarism in a dissertation is okay.

Breaking the Spell of Silence – talking about plagiarism 

Dr. Conrad Kunze,
Lecturer at the Chair of Environmental Issues in Social Sciences
Technical University of Cottbus

The most obvious thing about plagiarism in a university should be the public shaming of offenders. And usually there is quite a consensus amongst professors and lecturers when it comes to complaints about students and the need to be harsh with frauds. Who would hesitate to reject a Bachelor's Thesis in which a page copied from Wikipedia is found? Probably no one.

So why not also reject a PhD Thesis if even more than a page is copied? Probably no one? The story looks different, as I learned during the last two weeks.

I did not expect, that it was exceptionally easy to get support from officials for a case that shows a lack of scientific standards at the faculty and university in general. But that a blame game would start, in which I should be the offender was nevertheless a surprise.

It all started with a a few colleges who told me quite politely, but with a raised eyebrow, to stop talking about the case. Then, on a Friday the 13th, the voices criticizing me turned to a hysteric high tone. After a public presentation, two colleagues blamed me for “pulling the commission for scientific standards through the dirt”, for starting a “witch-hunt”, celebrating a “tribunal” and so on. How had it come so far?

A day before I had invited colleges and students to a presentation in which I explained as precisely as possible, why I hold the PhD in question to be a case of plagiarism beyond all doubt (as everyone could see in VroniplagWiki), although some criticism of the university commission that had just come to the opposite result was inevitable. Nevertheless, I tried to give all the rational reasons that had motivated me. I hoped to initiate a sober discussion, based on facts, not accusations.

Two weeks before, I read in a national newspaper about the plagiarism case at my university. The paper made quite a scandal of the commission´s decision not to rate the PhD thesis invalid. The proof is online at Vroniplag Wiki. Page for page and line for line, 52 pages out of a 119 page thesis are shown to be copied from other sources without proper citation.

After a quick click on the Vroniplag Wiki I grew more and more curious and surprised, if that ought to be right, that the PhD was a complete fraud. Knowing from experience that normal questions are usually ignored or brushed away, I wrote an open letter to the university´s president, asking if we should not consider to change the statutes. If that PhD was not a case of plagiarism with 44 % of all pages with incomplete citation, then what was still plagiarism, less than 44 %? Would it not be easier to save precious time and give up all the controls for scientific authenticity?

Of course the question was quite polemic, but it helped to make the problem of a double standard clear. Normal students would have probably failed. The PhD in question was written by Mr. Dähnert, who is a high ranking official at Vattenfall. This is a company that contributes millions of Euro to the university´s research activity every year. Of course that is not a proof, but isn´t it reasonable to be even more careful with such a PhD and treat it with highest scrutiny?

One can only answer "no" with the premise, that high amounts of money do not influence an organization. But experience has shown rather the opposite tendency. Large amounts of money usually have a certain influence, as the receiving organization might try to avoid losing that support.

Withdrawing the PhD would have meant risking a confrontation between the university and a high-ranking official of one of its important economic partners. As experience has shown, some of those who lost their PhD – especially people of public interest – initiated law suits against their universities.

After Thursday night's presentation, quite a number of people congratulated me for going public, wishing good luck for this struggle, although they did so personally or in private e-mails. The opposing side, university officials and those colleges who were part of the commission, criticized me openly in mailing lists.

What had happened? The usual silence that falls on important political questions was broken. I had dared to talk about a case many had thought and blogged about anonymously in the internet. But assembling with like-thinking colleges and students was something very different.

When the local media reported widely the following Friday, the silence was broken. The more brave ones started to talk openly on the topic and the university´s officials faced a pressure to act towards reopening the case.

The struggle against an attitude of “let's close our eyes on this and not think about it any more” is also a struggle for freedom of speech. The atmosphere of fear that surrounds the case was summarized by a college who told me “You are in the position to do this, but I have just started my PhD and a work position, so how could I dare to?"

I do not plan to get a new contract in TU Cottbus anyway, other people do. That is why the lot fell on me to scandalize what in my opinion, after studying the proof on Vroniplag Wiki, deserves to be a scandal.

Last week the commission started re-considering the case, only half-officially and half-heartedly, but at least there is some movement. After all, public pressure had succeeded over the spell of silence, thanks to many people´s efforts and contributions, at Vroniplag Wiki, the local media, colleges and students!

Saturday, July 21, 2012

Dutch Researcher Admits Cooking Data

The group blog "The Monkey Cage" reports on a case in the Netherlands (reports in Dutch and English) in which a Belgian marketing professor at the Erasmus University in Rotterdam, Dirk Smeesters, admitted that he cooked his data.

His results had seemed too good to be true, so after a whistleblower alerted the university an investigation was launched to replicate the data. When this failed, he was asked to produce the original data. He first cited computer problems and then an office move before finally admitting that he had removed data that didn't fit his theory. The university has requested the retraction of his paper from the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, published by the American Psychological Associateion and from the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, published by Elsevier. Both papers are, however, still on sale online.

Interestingly, Smeesters has claimed that this is the "normal" way of working in his field.  If this is indeed the case, there may be more retractions to follow.

ScienceInsider reports that he has now resigned and has further details on the case. RetractionWatch has CV information that has been removed from the university web page.


Friday, July 20, 2012

The German Dissertation Factory

The daily newspaper Main Post reports on the current state of investigations into the German "dissertation factory" at the medical faculty of the University of Würzburg. The university is doing its best, the article says, to dig out under the investigation of 20 dissertations, of which four are found to be plagiarized.

In 2009 the prosecutor's office investigated claims that a Würzburg medical professor who had had over 200 students write their dissertations with him was selling titles. Or rather, he was accepting loans to fund his research. He was fined for taking bribes. In May 2011 an anonymous dossier turned up with many names and dates - but there was no way to prove that money had been exchanged here for titles, so the case was officially closed, the professor is now retired. The person who arranged for the prospective doctoral students to be accepted and took a 1000 € fee for this was, however, fined.

The university was somewhat skittish about the situation and started an investigation into the matter. 20 of the theses were of a very questionable nature - I have seen some of the theses, for example one by a dentist writing a short dissertation (27 pages) in the field of the history of medicine by transcribing fifteenth century texts about the pharmaceutical use of some flowers. Not analyzing anything, not translating, just transcribing. The university has determined that four of the theses are plagiarisms to boot, and has decided to rescind the doctorates. The persons in question are, as seems usual in Germany, taking the university to court in the hopes of keeping their titles because the university has made some procedural error.

When the newspaper tried to contact one of the dentists involved a lawyer answered forbidding any reporting that might point to his client - who is apparently a friend of a former governor of a German state.

I wish the university a strong case in court - and hope that they set up procedures for not accepting theses like this ever again.

Update: Just including a link to an in-depth article at Zeit online about this case from 2012.

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

German Professor retracts two papers from Research Policy

I have been alerted to the following two retractions at Research Policy:
Retraction Watch has the report that the author has voluntarily retracted a third paper:
  • Ulrich Lichtenthaler and Holger Ernst, Technology licensing strategies: the interaction of process and content characteristics, Strategic Organization,  Vol 7(2): 183–221, DOI: 10.1177/1476127009102672
Retraction Watch also gives a link to a Handelsblatt biography of Lichtenthaler (in German). Lichtenthaler is currently a professor at the University of Mannheim. The question arises as to whether these papers were instrumental in his obtaining the professorship, and how the university needs to react in the face of the retractions.

One paper was retracted because it was apparently a multiple publication (self-plagiarism), the others for statistical issues. Germany has no national policy on retractions, and even though some universities have ethical codices, there is often no clear road to follow when something like this comes up. With the amount of ethical problems being uncovered in Germany recently, one would think that there would be a national committee investigating. If there is, I am unaware of it.

Update August 16, 2012:  Retractionwatch has documented a fourth retraction by Lichtenthaler, this time from Strategic Management Journal.

Sunday, July 15, 2012

VroniPlag Wiki - Case 27 again from Münster

VroniPlag Wiki has published the 27th case on its home page, again a doctoral dissertation from the University of Münster in law. This author of this dissertation, as was the author of the 26th case, was a co-author of the law textbook that VroniPlag Wiki put up as the 25th case. The text parallels in case 27 are different from the ones in case 26. Where the latter had a lot of identical text, the former often has what is termed a "pawn sacrifice". The source is given, but the extent of the text that was taken is not made clear.

Münster was also the university where a duplicate dissertation in the medical faculty was discovered by chance by someone researching an article for the Wikipedia. They also granted a dissertation in medicine on the basis of a four page article co-authored by the doctoral advisor.

It seems that the law and medicine faculties there might need a refresher course on good scientific practice. I hope that the university makes it very clear what steps they are taking to insure that future dissertations do not include plagiarisms.

Thursday, July 12, 2012

Just Technical Weaknesses

VroniPlag Wiki case #16 has been decided by the BTU Cottbus (previously reported here) to only contain "technical weaknesses", although VroniPlag Wiki has found massive text parallels on 44% of the pages. The university issued a statement that the committee only found technical weaknesses, but that they will not publish their results because of "data privacy concerns". I suggest having a look at my favorite pages and forming your own opinion: 028 - 034 and 035 - 048 - 103. There are more pages. Many more.
 
In the wake of this, there is outrage at the University of Cottbus. Teachers are asking how they can fail their students for plagiarism if this amount of blatant plagiarism is acceptable in a dissertation. A teacher published an open letter and gave a lecture about the case in Cottbus this evening. The person who did the research for the thesis (and is not named) has also come forward. VroniPlag Wiki has posted these documents (including a link to the audio file for this evening's lecture) and a discussion about them in the forums area.

Perhaps it helps to understand the university's decision to know that the person granted the doctoral degree in 1999 is CEO of the Vattenfall Carbon Storage division. Vattenfall is one of the largest companies in the region and the company that gives the university about 1/3 of its research budget.

It will be interesting to see if the protest continues, or if it dies down because the semester break is rapidly approaching.

Update: 14.7.2012 - fixed the company division Dähnert works for